Lightweight and Loaded Subnotes

SAN FRANCISCO (05/26/2000) - Toshiba Corp.'s 3.4-pound Portégé 3440CT notebook and Fujitsu Ltd.'s even lighter-weight LifeBook B-2131 deliver a hardware punch that belies their subnotebook size. Both are ideal for travelers who need to access e-mail and use Windows apps but who don't want to lug around a heavy notebook.

My preproduction $2499 Portégé 3440CT came with a crisp 11.3-inch active-matrix display, a mobile Pentium III-500 processor, a 6GB hard drive, 64MB of SDRAM, an S3 Savage/IX graphics accelerator with 8MB of integrated video memory, and a built-in 56-kbps modem. The lithium ion battery lasted about 2.5 hours on a single charge. For an extra $459, you can add a high-capacity battery slice that provides an astonishing 8-plus hours of power but also nearly doubles the unit's thickness and weight. The standard OS is Windows 98, but you can request Windows 2000.

The 3.1-pound Fujitsu LifeBook B-2131 costs $500 less than the Portégé 3440CT, but it has a slower Celeron-400 CPU and a less impressive Trident Cyber 9525 DVD video chip set with 2.5MB of video memory. Its 10.4-inch active-matrix touch screen is glare-prone but allows you to use a stylus instead of a joystick pointing device. The LifeBook also comes with 64MB of SDRAM and a 6GB hard drive. Its lithium ion battery lasted only about 2 hours in my informal tests with a shipping unit, however. Fujitsu preloads either Windows 98 SE or Windows 2000.

The differences between these two portables become apparent when you put the machines to real-world use. Consider keyboard design: The Fujitsu's keyboard is noticeably more comfortable to type on than the Portégé's--offering more spring and superior user feedback--even though its keys are slightly smaller.

Regrettably, what the LifeBook B-2131 adds in user comfort it subtracts in awkward key placement. For example, "Delete" is a half-size key above "Backspace", and the notebook-specific "Fn" key sits where we expect to find "Ctrl"--making typing errors all too easy.

These ultraportables pack an amazing number of conventional notebook ports: two USB ports, one PC Card slot, and an ethernet port on the Fujitsu; one USB port and two PC Card slots on the Toshiba. But with either unit, you still must carry the included sub-3-ounce external port replicator if you want PS/2, serial, or parallel ports (or an ethernet port for the Toshiba). Each notebook comes with an external floppy drive.

Not surprisingly--in light of its beefier CPU--the Portégé turned in noticeably zippier performance in my informal tests: Still, the LifeBook performed most business tasks quite satisfactorily.

Both the LifeBook and the Portégé are high-quality portables that fit easily in an attaché case or suitcase. The Portégé is not a great value, however, since you have to pay $578 more for the external CD-ROM drive and the required, upgraded SelectBay Port Replicator (which replaces the one included with the notebook). Fujitsu charges only $269 for an external CD-ROM drive. The hefty premium that Toshiba imposes for its superior power and its sharper, larger screen makes the Fujitsu a better deal overall.

Fujitsu LifeBook B-2131

Pro: Has an integrated modem and an ethernet port.

Con: Bright but glare-prone touch screen; comfortable keyboard is marred by poor key placement.

Value: Power, low price make for excellent subnotebook value.

List price: $1999

Fujitsu PC

800/733-0884

www.fujitsu-pc.com

Toshiba Portégé 3440CT

Pro: Large screen for a subnotebook; strong performance.

Con: Price doesn't cover external CD-ROM drive, and unit requires special (and costly) port replicator.

Value: Strong product, but extras cost too much.

List price: $2499

Toshiba

800/867-4422

www.toshiba.com.

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about FujitsuToshiba

Show Comments