Pundits Say The Darndest Things

Upshot: The media didn't just cover Tuesday's sell-off. It promoted it.

Calling the Plays or Running Them? Eyeballed by the Net, CNNfn, and, above all, CNBC, Tuesday's selling got real-time commentary that, almost before the fact, pegged it as "a sell-off" or something like one.

Go Deep and Throw Long: On cue, stock fans rushed the field. Trouble is, markets work better at allocating capital and setting prices when investors make their decisions independently.

Quote: "[I]t's a recipe for increased volatility. So huge price swings are probably with us to stay."

Upshot: Tracking stocks are yet another corporate dodge.

What They Teach You in School: Stocks tied to the value of a particular part of a business let investors buy into only what they like.

What It All Really Means: Trackers are a popular trick for companies to goose up share price and convince investors that things are better than they seem.

We're Not Seeing Any Hands Out There: If no one knows what tracking stocks are, "why not get rid of them and let companies do a better job of explaining their true value to investors?"

Upshot: So wisdom says stocks dip when their lockup period expires? This market could give a hoot.

Watch Out for Averages: Stock prices typically fall 10 percent to 15 percent in the days immediately surrounding a lockup expiration date.

Forget Physics: But trying to take advantage of the "lockup effect" can easily backfire. Shares of CareInsite, a Web-based medical supply company, jumped $5 a share, from $72 to $77.50, on Dec. 12, the day its lockup expired. Commerce One saw its price climb $57 the day before its lockup expired on Dec. 28.

Quote: "[N]othing in this abnormal market can be expected to function normally, all the time - not even the laws of supply and demand.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about CareInsiteCNBCCommerce One

Show Comments