Hiring and firing with respect

Book author says employee respect starts with your respect

"I get no respect." If that's how you feel your employees are treating you, it's possible they're just reflecting the attitude you're showing them, according to Ruth Hagg, author of a series of management books.

"Respect is a two-way street," says the Sandusky, Ohio-based writer of Hiring and Firing: Book Three, the third volume in a four-part series titled Taming Your Inner Supervisor.

Hagg, a former supervisor who got into writing after analyzing her own management style, says respect for one's workers starts with the hiring process.

Respect, she says, becomes most important when it's time to lay off an employee and "you're delivering news that could affect their financial and emotional well-being."

If not done with compassion and respect, Hagg says, a layoff can hurt a company's bottom line and cause permanent damage to its reputation.

Such was the case when electronics retailer RadioShack of Fort Worth, decided to e-mail dismissal notices to more than 400 of its employees in a mass layoff on August 29 this year, said Hagg. The dismissals, portrayed as "calloused" in several publications, were later called "cyberfiring."

The company received a public relations black eye when reports began appearing in the media that sacked employees received a terse e-mail from management that read: "The workplace reduction notification is currently in progress. Unfortunately, your position is one of those that has been eliminated."

"It's bad enough to be laid off, but to be told off in an e-mail worsens the situation," said Hagg.

Characterizing the RadioShack's dismissal method as "a rookie mistake," Hagg said the fiasco also demoralized the rest of the employees and could discourage future hires.

Wendy Dominguez, manager of corporate media relations for RadioShack, however, said the company engaged in a long process of information dissemination and meetings with employees about the impending layoffs.

A timeline of events, provided by Dominguez to IT World Canada, indicated that on August 10, the company released a press statement about a planned reduction targeted for "early September." Julian Day, RadioShack CEO, e-mailed employees assuring them they would be treated with "dignity and respect" throughout the process.

Four information meetings were held on August 17, to tell employees the layoff date was set for August 29. Workers were told they would receive a "personalized e-mail" notifying them that they had to attend a face-to-face meeting with their senior leader.

On August 29, the e-mail messages were sent out.

RadioShack said workers who were let go were given time to say good-bye to co-workers and an opportunity to sign up for a time to come back for remaining personal items.

Dominguez said the company thought sending an e-mail would be the most appropriate method to deal with a mass layoff situation. "We believed that individual, personal e-mail notification would be the most private means of letting affected employees know they were to meet with their senior leader."

Hagg, however, noted that corporate dismissals were often an unsavory moment for the person being fired as well as the individual giving the discharge notice. She suspects reluctance to meet this situation head on could have something to do with choosing e-mail as a method for informing the employees.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about BossFord MotorHISRadioShackRegal

Show Comments