There's no such thing as a free email service, at least not when it comes to Google, according to industry analysts.
Google got slammed this week after longtime Google critic Consumer Watchdog lit up the Internet by pointing out a legal argument that Google attorneys made during a class-action lawsuit about the company's practice of scanning Gmail messages for key words to help target advertising.
"Just as a sender of a letter to a business colleague cannot be surprised that the recipient's assistant opens the letter, people who use web-based email today cannot be surprised if their communications are processed by the recipient's ECS [electronic communications service] provider in the course of delivery," Google's attorneys wrote in a motion ( download PDF).
And then quoting a 1979 case, Smith v. Maryland, they added, "Indeed, "a person has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information he voluntarily turns over to third parties."
When that comment became public, it unleashed an online firestorm about Google's privacy policies and a debate about whether people should expect privacy in their personal or business emails.
"We take our users' privacy and security very seriously; recent reports claiming otherwise are simply untrue," wrote a Google spokesperson in an email to Computerworld. "We have built industry-leading security and privacy features into Gmail -- and no matter who sends an email to a Gmail user, those protections apply."
Google doesn't have a roomful of employees sitting at desks reading everyone's personal Gmail messages. What the company does have is an automated delivery process that scans incoming emails for spam, viruses and keywords that help it target advertising to users.
"I think the real issue here is nave users thinking that they can get something for nothing," said Dan Olds, an analyst with The Gabriel Consulting Group. "Providers don't do anything for free. There's always an angle they're playing to either increase their revenue or profitability. And Google takes a back seat to no one when it comes to figuring out and exploiting all the angles. One of the best angles is using email contents to aim specific ads at users."
He added that it's a common practice for email service providers to scan messages for things like spam and advertising keywords.
"It's true that these are automated filters, not human beings, reading the emails and matching up the ads," said Olds. "I don't think consumers see this as a huge invasion of privacy, not because they don't have anything to hide, but mainly because they've never given it a thought. For most users, I think their main thought is "cool, free email" rather than "I wonder why this is free? What are they getting out of it?" "
Rob Enderle, an analyst with the Enderle Group, said he doesn't see this ruckus as something that will drive people to abandon their Gmail accounts.
"Free email is paid for in some way -- Google mines it, others use it as a way to sell you on additional services they provide. You pick your poison," he added. "The value of your profile is hidden from you and then you effectively exchange it for a set of services.... Google is incredibly profitable, suggesting that value is much higher than we likely realize."
Patrick Moorhead, an analyst with Moor Insights & Strategy, said that since people actively click a link or check a box saying they accept Google's terms of service, it's hard to complain when the company does what it said it was going to do.
"I do not think very many users will leave Gmail over this," he added. "As we have seen with other publicity over privacy [issues] with Facebook and other social media services, these flare-ups rarely result in lost users."
Enderle noted that people need to be more aware of what they're agreeing to in the first place.
"People should recognize that free comes with a cost," he added. "If they don't know what the cost is, it would be wise to find out."
Sharon Gaudin covers the Internet and Web 2.0, emerging technologies, and desktop and laptop chips for Computerworld. Follow Sharon on Twitter at @sgaudin, on Google+ or subscribe to Sharon's RSS feed. Her email address is firstname.lastname@example.org.
Read more about privacy in Computerworld's Privacy Topic Center.