Federating identity for the Web

User-centric innovations CardSpace and OpenID may finally bring the promise of federation within reach

As for providing security assurance, CardSpace is built on standards such as WS-Trust, Secure Token Service, and WS-Security. As a result, CardSpace benefits from the public security reviews of these standards. And because both CardSpace and OpenID are open architectures, thorough security reviews of each are possible.

The biggest threat to individuals is the so-called "social engineering" that any identity system allows. Of these, phishing poses the biggest threat at present, and OpenID, like any Web-based authentication scheme, is especially vulnerable. CardSpace's identity selector was invented specifically to foil phishing and related attacks. Moreover, CardSpace's rigid insistence on a consistent user experience reduces the diverse authentication contexts users face when tapping Web-based authentication technologies, thereby increasing the likelihood that they will recognize something out of the ordinary when asked for credentials.

Crossing the identity chasm

User-centric technologies have already demonstrated that they can solve many of identity's most difficult problems. Yet user-centric identity currently stands overlooking Geoffrey Moore's product adoption chasm, having won over enthusiasts and visionaries, but awaiting widespread adoption from the more pragmatic early majority on the other side. To cross that chasm, user-centric technologies will have to pass several milestones in the next 12 to 24 months.

First, user-centric identity will need to be incorporated into more of the products enterprise users buy. "The challenge is that the pieces aren't there for organizations to deploy," Sxip's Hardt says. "If CA ships it with SiteMinder, then it's a configuration decision. When Microsoft ships ActiveDirectory with CardSpace built in, issuing managed cards will be easy."

Burton Group's Neuenschwander agrees. "On their own, they're not likely to be deployed. Enterprises will deploy OpenID and CardSpace through a federation or ESSO [enterprise single sign-on] product. That will be a safer and more functional way for enterprises to acquire and deploy these technologies," he says.

As for the likelihood of either technology gaining widespread vendor acceptance over the short term, Neuenschwander adds, "Most of the federation vendors are going to support interaction with CardSpace. For one thing, it will get them single sign-on capabilities with Microsoft environments like SharePoint and Exchange. That's all rolling out over the next year."

A related component is the identity selector itself. Microsoft has included it in Vista, but getting the identity selector anywhere else requires downloading and installing it. Incorporating identity selectors into the OS without a separate download will increase penetration and will eliminate one side of the chicken-and-egg problem that enterprises face with CardSpace in b-to-c scenarios.

On the standards front, OpenID 2.0, with standards for user-attribute exchange, is an important milestone. For CardSpace, watch for the ability to synchronize claims among multiple machines, including mobile claims functionality.

Early adopters

Although there's still much to be done before most organizations will embrace these technologies wholeheartedly, some deployments are already under way.

Product managers are one group likely to embrace user-centric identity early because they are being driven to understand and serve customers in innovative ways. Two examples: AOL and France Telecom have both deployed OpenID. "As b-to-c, consumer-facing companies, AOL and France Telecom will view user-centric identity as a competitive advantage," says Ping Identity's Durand.

The governments of British Columbia and Singapore have announced plans to roll out identity cards based on CardSpace for citizens. Federation does not scale for many government uses because in most cases governments can't dictate architecture the way powerful business partners can. That said, governments has long served as a foundational role for identity in society, and these early steps may in fact help businesses see the benefits of user-centric identity systems, especially as they expand the technology's user base.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about AOLBurton GroupCA TechnologiesFrance TelecomINSInteropLinuxMicrosoftMilestoneNovellPromiseProvisionProvisionRPS

Show Comments