Lack of BPO standards can mean higher IT costs

Business process outsourcing (BPO) is still so new that when Sharon Taylor, vice president of corporate human resources at Prudential Financial, describes her experience she has the authority of a veteran - even though her company is just four years into a seven-year contract.

But four years of experience is "about as mature as it gets in this space," said Taylor, who helped build a business case for Prudential, with some 40,000 employees, to outsource its human resources functions.

"There really wasn't much of a roadmap, but we knew the outcome that we needed to have," she told attendees at an IDC Outsourcing Forum. Prudential outsourced HR to Exult, which merged with Hewitt Associates in 2004.

Taylor, recently elected chair of the Human Resources Outsourcing Association in Washington, is now helping to write a roadmap that may help other users. The group is developing a set of best practices and "next practices" -- things that users are likely to need from service providers as the industry develops, she said.

BPO covers a galaxy of services, especially in financial services such as claims processing, reconciliation, collection, transaction services and tax preparation - anything that can be delivered via the Internet -- and is growing rapidly, according to IDC. Worldwide spending on BPO last year was about US$425 billion and is expected to grow 11% annually through 2009.

"It's definitely becoming a more accepted way of managing a business," said Katrina Menzigian, vice president of business solutions for BPO services research at IDC. "It's not quite mainstream but it's on the path."

One thing that many BPO services don't yet have are standards similar those commonly used in IT, such as the Information Technology Infrastructure Library (ITIL) and the Capability Maturity Model developed by Carnegie Mellon University Software Engineering Institute.

While there are some standards for business processes, they're far from universal and, more importantly, there's no push to adopt standards similar to the U.S. Department of Defense's support for Carnegie Mellon's software maturity standards.

If a vendor claims to be good at providing human resources BPO, "you have to take their word for it, because there is no standard for them to adhere [to]," said Tom Davenport, a professor of IT and management at Babson College in Mass. Davenport also spoke the conference.

This lack of BPO standards increases IT costs, said Davenport. If business services use various methods and procedures for processing similar work, that means applications must be customized to meet the unique needs of those internal processes. Business process commoditization would mean "less customization of software" and would also accelerate the use of BPO, he said.

Similarly, Michael Monaghan, senior vice president of Wachovia's outsourcing strategy group, said that some of the processes at his bank adhere to standards while others don't. "It's on a case-by-case basis; It's not universal or ubiquitous." But standards would help reduce cost in areas such as application support, he said.

Prudential's Taylor believes the work of the association she now heads may ultimately help users develop better performance measures for checking the work of a service provider, and use that collective experience to create "a convergence of what excellence looks like."

Join the newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

More about BillionCarnegie Mellon University AustraliaExultHewitt AssociatesHISIDC AustraliaMellonPrudentialVIAWachovia

Show Comments