Three Tips for Negotiating a Better Pay Package

Executives may feel they're at a disadvantage when negotiating the details of a pay package with a new employer. But you can level the playing ground by knowing your priorities and a few facts.

Take Steven McAllister, who recently negotiated a new job as director of sales development for Autodesk, a California-based software company. He focused on his base salary during the discussions in September, "because so many things are based on your salary, such as the size of your life insurance or your long-term disability payments," he says.

Craig Scott, director of capital markets for Cano Petroleum, an oil and gas production company in Fort Worth, Texas, concentrated on the size of his stock-option package when he negotiated the pay for his job in July. If he feels that the company's stock might be a hard sell, he requests more options than if he thinks it will be a highflier.

High-level executives often ask financial experts or lawyers to help secure their next pay deal and work out the details. If you're a typical executive, you won't have this advantage. But by knowing your negotiating priorities, the value of your current pay package vs. the new employer's offer, and the going rate of pay for the job, you can bargain effectively for yourself. Start with these three steps:

1. Determine what's most important. What are your deal-breakers? Before you begin discussions, be clear about areas where you won't budge. McAllister, who had been a vice president and general manager at Gateway, wanted Autodesk to agree to a higher salary than it first offered before he accepted his position. Ultimately, the company offered him a salary that exceeded his minimum requirement.

Scott says he wanted the minimum potential value of his option grant at Cano Petroleum to be US$1 million in the first year or two. He also asked for the option-exercise price to be set at the price the stock was currently trading when he received the grant.

"My job is to make the stock go up," he says. If the exercise price is set below the current market price, "it's a freebie," he adds.

2. Know what you earn and how your offer compares to other executives' pay. Many executives don't know what they're making, say compensation consultants. "Typically, the higher they are up the food chain, the less they know what their compensation is," says Paul Dorf, managing director of Compensation Resources, a consulting firm based in Saddle River, N.J.

Bone up by writing down the value of your annual salary and any cash bonuses you're due to receive. Know when your next salary increase is due and what you'd make after receiving it. Salary increases for executives are expected to average 3.8% in 2006, reports Mercer Human Resource Consulting.

Find out what other executives in your function and industry are earning. Many Web sites provide data on cash pay in various functions and industries.

Place a value on each item in your benefits package, such as your medical, dental and other insurance plans, company match of a 401(k) plan and accrued vacation time. If you receive a company car, country club membership or other perk, "put a value on it," says Alan Johnson, managing director of Johnson Associates, a New York-based compensation consulting firm.

According to consulting firm Watson Wyatt, the average value of a company-owned car ranged from US$5,444 for professionals to US$11,271 for CEOs in 2005. The average annual cost of financial counseling was US$2,705 for a senior manager and US$6,060 for a CEO, the company reports.

Value any stock options you have with your current employer. For prepublic companies, this usually isn't possible. The best you can do is determine the current value based on the exercise price and your best guess of a company's future prospects, says Mark Edwards, chairman of Compensia, a compensation consulting firm in San Jose. For public companies, using an online stock-option calculator can help you to figure this amount.

3. Understand a new employer's long-term incentives and the size of probable payouts. Employers are moving away from stock options as incentives because of new accounting rules. A long-term incentive package for executives now might include stock options, restricted stock grants (shares that vest after a certain period of time) or another type of stock grant based on performance, says Edwards.

"The mix of pay on the equity side is changing rapidly," he says.

Since long-term incentives are typically linked to company performance, knowing a company's past history of incentive payouts can help you calculate the potential value of any long-term incentives you're offered, says Steve Van Putten, a Boston-based executive-compensation practice leader for Watson Wyatt.

"Ask what a company's history of payouts is relative to the target goals in its long-term performance programs," he says. "If the plan funded at 75% of target for the past three years, then you should discount your incentive opportunity by 25%."

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about Autodesk AustraliaGatewayHIS

Show Comments