Communications Minister Stephen Conroy has kept mum in the face of burning questions on structural separation and regulation for the National Broadband Network (NBN).
Conroy on Tuesday took questions asked in a Senate Estimates hearing on notice, citing probity, and refused to discuss the NBN further than narrating tender documents.
He said doing so would undermine the RFP, and "risk inadvertent comment".
Liberal senator for South Australia Simon Birmingham criticised the minister for refusing to confirm whether the NBN will require structural separation.
"RFP appears to be open to structural separation [which] leaves open all manner of possibilities," Birmingham said.
"You have avoided scrutiny on the process. The government had every opportunity in the world to change the RFP [and] it's amazing you have shut down any discussion in the development stage.
"You seem to think the same ASX provision that applies to a public float would apply to the broadband tender. Every question is ruled out."
Structural separation is not a requirement of the RFP, however page nine of the tender document states that bidders with wholesale and retail operations should "demonstrate" what structures they have in place to avoid a network monopoly.
Conroy took questions on structural separation requirements on notice regarding statements earlier this month at the Sydney Institute where the minister said he would "carefully look at structural arrangements similar to those adopted in countries such as UK , NZ and Singapore" for the NBN.
"Anything more than opening statements I'll take it on notice," Conroy said.
The minister confirmed he consulted Finance and Deregulation minister Lindsay Tanner, the former broadband expert taskforce, and central department agencies regarding network separation, but refused to divulge discussions between the two.
Labor Senator for the ACT Kate Lundy attacked opposition statements that NBN proposals issued by the Tasmanian government would jeopardise the network,
"The Coalition has completely bungled it up and has egg on it's face," Lundy said, speaking in regards to a press release issued by shadow communications minister Bruce Billson.
The RFP considers NBN proposals submitted by states and territories, provided they meet network requirements and can contribute to coverage.
Shadow minister Billson said government has littered the NBN with gag clauses.
"This government has so far gagged a senate inquiry, gagged potential bidders from discussing it, gagged parliament from debating legislation relating to it and now in its latest attack against the parliamentary process has attempted to gag estimates," Billson said in a statement.
Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services. Strategies for Eliminating .PST Files
Gaining Competitive Advantage Through Enterprise Planning
Everything you need to know about email and web security (but were afraid to ask)
Achieving the impossible: Unlimited application scalability
Business Intelligence and Enterprise Performance Management: Trends for Emerging Businesses
Enterprise Wireless WLAN Security
CRM your salespeople will love
Email Archiving 101—Customer Case Study
Zones provide focussed content from Computerworld and leading technology partners.Discover how SOA can create smarter outcomes for your business.
Attend and learn:
- How SOA is helping leading companies to become more agile
- Where you should be applying SOA processes in your company
- The top SOA implementation mistakes to avoid
Click here for more information.
- +
Computerworld Live Podcast #97: The Future of Enterprise Networking 25/07/2008 09:45:36
This week CW Live chats with Mark Thompson, global sales and marketing manager for HP ProCurve, on the future of the enterprise networking. Mark discusses the trends we can expect to see in the near future and how the right infrastructure can ensure your enterprise network is secure. - +
Computerworld Live Podcast #96: Security at the Edge 11/06/2008 09:22:22
CW Live speaks with Amol Mitra, HP ProCurve Director of Marketing for Asia Pacific and Japan. Today's topic: how enterprises are starting to shift away from simply controlling security via server logins, firewalls and moving to more adaptive security frameworks. - +
Data Management Edition #10: Multi-Petascale Systems 02/05/2008 09:12:33
This week we look at sustainability and the development of multicore technologies to build multi-petascale systems. - +
IT Security Edition #11: How to poison the Storm botnet 01/05/2008 08:51:55
This week CW Live presents a case study on how to poison the notorious Storm botnet . Plus we take a look at Cisco's plans for Ironport. - +
IT Security Edition #10: Cyber-battles fought and won 24/04/2008 11:09:47
Vendors bow to end user pressure to improve product security, and we take a look at the latest concepts shaping the cyber-battlefield of the future.
PGP and Ponemon Institute Unveil Inaugural Australian Data Breach Study 2008 2008-11-20 17:34:00+11
Symantec Cloud Services Transform Data Centre Operations Through Proactive Management 2008-11-20 12:06:00+11
Verizon Business Offers Tips to Building a Successful Unified Communications and Collaboration Plan 2008-11-20 12:04:00+11
AARNet Brings 4K Digital Cinema to Australia: First 4K HD Video Signal delivered into Australia by AARNet 2008-11-20 12:02:00+11
NetApp Named 2008 Citrix Ready Solution of the Year by Citrix Systems 2008-11-20 11:33:00+11
Radicati Market Quadrant 2008 on Corporate Web Security
An Analysis of the Market for Corporate Web Security Solutions, revealing Top Players, Mature Players, Specialists and Trail Blazers. Read on to discover who makes the grade.









