HFC NBN just fine for Telepresence: Cisco

'HFC is the right option for the country,' says Cisco vice president, Ken Boal

Cisco vice president of ANZ, Ken Boal

Cisco vice president of ANZ, Ken Boal

Cisco has endorsed using hybrid-fibre cable (HFC) as a more expedient way to connect 3 million homes to Australia’s National Broadband Network.

"HFC is the right option for the country,” Ken Boal, Cisco vice president for ANZ, told media at the Cisco Live conference in Melbourne.

“It’s faster to deploy because the infrastructure is already there ... for 3 million homes,” he said. “It’s therefore much more cost-effective to deploy. We believe that 3 million homes in a very relatively short period of time, and it’s less than four years.”

The statement supports the Coalition government and NBN Co's proposal to use HFC as part of a multi-technology approach to rolling out the NBN. The previous Labor government had backed an all fibre-to-the-premises plan.

Boal said that poor broadband capability could be a contributing factor to slowing growth of Cisco’s video business, which he said has plateaued in the Australian market. Cisco has a tough time selling bandwidth-demanding video services like Telepresence to Australian homes served with insufficient Internet services like ADSL.

“To get high-definition video working reliably with business applications in the home is very difficult,” said Boal. “No matter how good your residential broadband service is, [with] the contention ratio of that link, it’s damn hard.”

The NBN could change all that, he said.

“We haven’t seen anything yet in terms of residential video, so what NBN will enable is a new opportunity for residential video B2C,” said Boal. Cisco envisions a range of B2C video applications for healthcare, education and financial wealth management, he said.

That relationship between broadband and video takeup has been seen in other countries, said Geoff Lawrie, Cisco country manager for New Zealand. In Norway, for example, affordable access to high-speed broadband strongly drove video penetration in the home, he said.

Unlike fibre, HFC is an asymmetric technology with download speeds that greatly exceed its upload speeds. However, Boal said Cisco believes HFC will still be effective for its videoconferencing services.

The contention ratios and backhaul for HFC “are more than adequate,” he said. “We would [not] be putting HFC forward as a credible alternative if we thought there was backhaul constraints in the platform.”

In addition, he said a newly released video codec, H.265, will offer compressed 1080p video at 1Mbps, bringing higher quality video at lower requirements.

Boal said Cisco is looking at other ways “kickstart” adoption of video. “The collaborative workplaces still aren’t as flexible and … we could still do a bit better.”

“For example, the price point of the existing platforms – it’s quite cost prohibitive to have a high-definition quality experience in the home or every office.”

In addition, Cisco has been working to make videoconferencing in large rooms more natural, with multiple cameras that can detect and zoom in on whoever is speaking, he said.

Adam Bender flew to Melbourne as a guest of Cisco.

Adam covers telco and enterprise tech issues for Computerworld and is the author of a dystopian novel about surveillance. Follow him on Twitter: @WatchAdam

Follow Computerworld Australia on Twitter: @ComputerworldAU, or take part in the Computerworld conversation on LinkedIn: Computerworld Australia

Tags telepresencehfcciscovideoconferencingNBNbroadbandvideo

More about ANZ Banking GroupCisco Systems Australia

9 Comments

Frank

1

At least he's up front that his motivation is to make more money. Why would he care what technology is used for the NBN if it allows him to sell more stuff short term? He doesn't have to worry about long term issues.

Eric

2

It should be stressed that this is for a very specific application for which the limitations of asymmetric bandwidth have a relatively low impact. For services such as cloud storage the story is very different.

Rex

3

Our internet connection is via HFC and it's not a great carriage service. Shared media and therefore very subject to congestion it is problematic in it stability and generally not as good as the ADSL service it replaced.

bluetie

4

It's not hard to see why all the equipment suppliers seem to think that substituting other systems for the NBN FTTP is a great idea.
First they get to sell the govt all the gear to patch up HFC and FTTN, concepts that will be out of date by the time they finish installing them.
Then they get to supply the FTTP equipment needed for a proper national network. So everybody's grinning, except for all the endusers who have to put up with this rubbish because of political bloody-mindedness.

Daniel

5

Cisco would, they are a manufacture.

http://www.cisco.com/en/US/netsol/ns842/networking_solutions_solution.html

http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/tech/broadband-cable/radio-frequency-rf-hybrid-fiber-coaxial-hfc/index.html

Talk about vested interests....

I would rather take a word from New Zealand, who went through FTTN trial, and then moved on to FTTP because FTTN sucked.

Observer

6

Who supplies most of the DOCSIS Cable routers in Australia?
Who has a lot to gain from HFC in NBN ?
- Hint, starts with C and ends with O

Optamizn

7

"Adam Bender flew to Melbourne as a guest of Cisco." that says it all right there...

Davy Adams

8

Adam's article isn't an opinion piece, Optamizn. It's a report on what Cisco's VP considers to be the correct option for the NBN. Clearly Cisco will have its perspective and other organisations will have theirs. Adam's job is to cover those independently. If he writes an opinion piece saying *he thinks* XYZ, then you might have justification in saying "that says it all right there"

bluetie

9

Not an opinion piece? No, of course not; Cisco just flew him to Melbourne because they felt like it. No pressure at all for a favourable wrap about their commercial expectations.
Move along people, nothing to see here...

Comments are now closed

Enterprise must shake core to be innovative: Telstra

READ THIS ARTICLE
DO NOT SHOW THIS BOX AGAIN [ x ]