Court to hear Telstra, NBN Co dispute next month

$100 million is estimated to be at stake

Telstra and NBN Co are headed back to the NSW Supreme Court on December 13 after a directions hearing was held this morning presided over by Justice David Hammerschlag.

The two organisations are in dispute over when consumer-price-index (CPI) adjustments apply to the price that Telstra charges NBN Co to access its infrastructure.

The dispute relates to the $11 billion agreement in which Telstra agreed to migrate its customers to the NBN and decommission its copper network, as well as allow NBN Co access to its pits, pipes and ducts.

The agreement allowed for CPI increases from the first of January every year after the commencement of the agreement. However, Telstra and NBN Co have disagreed over the precise date that the agreement commenced.

The agreement was signed in June 2011, so Telstra argues that CPI increases should take effect from 1 Jan 2012. However, NBN Co argues that the agreements were only finalised in March 2012, and so the CPI start date should be 1 Jan 2013.

The difference, depending on when CPI adjustments began, is estimated to be worth more than $100 million.

An attempt at mediation between the parties failed, resulting in Telstra taking NBN Co to court.

Telstra has said that the timing of the court action is unrelated to possible renegotitation of the deal with NBN Co, "although resolving this disagreement will help provide greater certainty and as such may assist future policy discussions."

The government has commissioned a 60-day review of NBN Co, which will include analysis of the progress and cost of the NBN rollout and NBN Co’s financial and operational status. The review is due for submission to the government for consideration by December 2.

The government plans to detail its new plan in a statement of expectations that will be released after the review is completed. The Coalition issued an interim statement of expectations last month to provide construction and operating guidance to the NBN Co during the audit.

Follow Adam Bender on Twitter: @WatchAdam

Follow Computerworld Australia on Twitter: @ComputerworldAU, or take part in the Computerworld conversation on LinkedIn: Computerworld Australia

Tags disputeNSW Supreme CourtCPIlegalnbn cocourtNBNTelstra

More about CPITelstra

3 Comments

blah

1

They're paying telstra 100million a year? just in cpi???

Francis Young

2

LOL, blah, read again!

Over the ten-year life of the project, Telstra is to receive migration fees for each copper customer moved onto fibre. The migration fee amount, to increase with inflation, was proposed in 2011, and agreed in 2012.

Telstra now wants the inflationary factor to be based on a 2011 start date instead of the 2012 agreement date, which, over the decade would amount collectively to an extra $100 million on the $11 billion total it is to receive.

I would suggest that the $100 million be held in an interest-bearing fund by the government as a completion bonus incentive.

Francis Young

3

Telstra now wants the inflationary factor to be based on a 2011 start date instead of the 2012 agreement date, which, over the decade would amount collectively to an extra $100 million on the $11 billion total it is to receive.

I would suggest that the $100 million be held in an interest-bearing fund by the government as a completion bonus incentive.

Comments are now closed

Optus 700MHz 4G network ready for Perth, Darwin

READ THIS ARTICLE
DO NOT SHOW THIS BOX AGAIN [ x ]