Turnbull launches broadband survey, but still no costed NBN plan

Malcolm Turnbull is looking to flesh out more of a Coalition NBN plan, but is still yet to provide hard figures on how much cheaper and faster it could roll out the NBN.

Malcolm Turnbull, shadow minister for communications and broadband, has launched a broadband survey to determine where the worst performing areas are in Australia to prioritise where the NBN needs to be rolled out.

“Our plan is to complete the construction of the National Broadband Network but to do so sooner, cheaper and more affordably for consumers,” Turnbull said in a statement.

While the Coalition has not yet formally outlined details of how it plans to develop the NBN if it comes into power in the next federal election in 2013, Turnbull said part of its approach would be to prioritise areas with poorly performing broadband services.

“This information [from the survey] will enable us to ensure that if we are elected to government the roll out of the NBN can be accelerated and targeted at the communities which need upgrades most,” he said.

“Many suburbs and towns are inadequately served by existing fixed line and mobile broadband, but Labor’s NBN is not the answer. It reduces competition, will increase the monthly cost of broadband and is, for many Australian households, many years in the future.”

Turnbull has been a strong opponent to key NBN agreements, such an $800 million agreement between NBN Co and Optus which was approved by the ACCC.

He has also consistently stated a fibre-to-the-node architecture would provide cheaper and faster access to the NBN.

“[The NBN] will not reach some Australians until the 2020s. And it will increase prices: The NBN business plan states that the monthly revenues it earns from each customer will triple between now and 2021,” he said.

However, Turnbull is yet to provide figures on how much sooner or cheaper the Coalition would be able to roll out the NBN, telling ABC Radio's AM program it is unable to produce a costed analysis of its NBN plan as it is unaware of the “extent to which [NBN Co] have made commitments”.

He also said NBN Co "doesn't have a very transparent approach to information", which makes it difficult for the Coalition to carry out a costed analysis of its alternative NBN plan.

Instead, Turnbull has provided rough guidelines on what the Coalition's NBN will look like, such as encouraging competition instead of “stamping it out”, which could involve overturning existing NBN Co agreements with telcos such as Telstra and Optus over their HFC networks.

Follow Stephanie McDonald on Twitter: @stephmcdonald0

Follow Computerworld Australia on Twitter: @ComputerworldAU


Charles Gregory


Absolutely disgusting Mr Turnbull. How many lies can you fit into one sentence? I think "It reduces competition, will increase the monthly cost of broadband and is, for many Australian households, many years in the future.” has the highest BS density ratio of this article.

Darren B


How low can you go Mr Turnbull? Don't you have any morals? Why lie to the Australian people to just try and win a few points from those you manage to fool? I can tell you now you are losing many from those that know what you are saying is utter rubbish.
A man of any integrity would do this to their own country. Putting petty politics ahead of the Australian people. Deceiving them and costing them and their children untold billions in future spending to rectify the mess you plan.



Don't worry, Turnbull will roll out the NBN.

Of course it won't be the NBN, but he's got enough hide to keep referring to his slightly cheaper and very nasty substitute as 'the NBN', which shows just what he thinks of the average person's intelligence.



Tried filling in Turnbull's survey. I am on his mailing list. Won't let me complete unless I put in internet specs at home, doesn't want to know about workplace or mobile access. Dodgy questionnaire.

Comments are now closed

TPG presence won't stop NBN Co installing FTTB equipment