Net filter protests fail to deliver crowds

Usual suspects show up at nationwide rallies
Few turnout to the Perth protest.
<I>credit:polemicol, flickr</i>

Few turnout to the Perth protest. credit:polemicol, flickr

UPDATE: Trish Zanetti at campaign organiser StoptheFilter estimates up to 300 people attended the Perth rally. She said numbers were effected by the short preparation time in the lead up to the event, and an environmental rally and the AC/DC concert held on the same day.

Nationwide protests against the Federal Government's Internet Content Filter plans held on Saturday struggled to draw big numbers.

Rallies were held in Perth, Sydney, Brisbane and Melbourne. The Parramatta Park event in Sydney attracted about 50 people, according to event organisers.

The low attendance has been a problem for the online activist groups since the rallies began in 2008, despite backing by the Greens, the Socialist Alliance and Electronic Frontiers Australia.

Greens Senator, Scott Ludlam, attended the Perth rally which included Curtin University Lecturer, Dr Mike Kent and Liberal Democratic Party WA president, Mark Walmsley.

Ludlam told Perth attendees that the fight against the Internet filtering plan will be "won and lost online".

"It's not about whether we trust Steven Conroy or Kevin Rudd," Ludlam said. "What about an Abbott Government, or the one after that? How will it be used the next time there is some kind of moral panic or terrorism attack somewhere in the world?

"Once instituted this will be impossible to roll back.

"We need these gatherings to exchange ideads and contact details and go and have a beer and strategise," he said.

Stop the filter

The Melbourne rally was reported to have drawn about 100 people.

Greens MP, Lee Rhiannon, told Sydney attendees the Internet filter would give parents a "false sense of the security" about online saftey.

"We need to ensure that sanity prevails and that we win the numbers [to] embarrass labor and the coalition that this is no way to protect children," Rhiannon said.

"I urge all of you to write emails, ring policticans, the public pressure really makes a difference. I say to Kevin Rudd and Tony Abott that this will not work... it will make us look like a fool locally and internationally."

Australia Sex Party president, Sarah Jenkins, returned to speak in support of the protest movement at the Melbourne rally at the State Library.

Sydney protest organiser Shaz Salimian proposed to re-organise under a new group free of political agenda.

"[The] Net Freedom Coalition will unify [groups] to stop the Internet filter. All groups are welcome and will not feel threatened that a political party will take advantage," Salimian said in an online video.

More about: Curtin University, Electronic Frontiers Australia, Federal Government
References show all

Comments

1

Max T

Mon 08/03/2010 - 10:51

This is due to the mainstream media REFUSING to publicise the filthy scheme.

Bought and paid for?

2

Ailie

Mon 08/03/2010 - 12:17

Can't say I'm surprised, I'm fully against the filter but knew little of these events. Why? Because I refuse to use Facebook and the only way to really get any information about them is through Facebook!

Apart from that, the best way to combat this issue is to educate the public so that they may eventually feel inclined to turn up to a rally such as this. The average Joe punter still doesn't know jack about this filter, and unless groups walk around malls, shopping centres, major events etc and tells people about it, they never will.

3

gth

Mon 08/03/2010 - 13:00

Well, let's see why Sydney failed to draw large crowds:

- multiple organising groups fractured about the location, having a rather public spat about it - basically a CBD vs. the West stance;

- the intent of the protest changed a few times: was it to be an education session?, a peaceful walk on the streets?, a run-amok rally of angry citizens?;

- the forecast was for the heavy storms to continue (sure enough it ended up being rather sunny on Saturday).

- Facebook is convenient for large events, however the sole organising email was blocked (Facebook reported an error when the link was clicked, instead of forwarding to the Parramatta Park website).

My family is disgusted by Labour's censorship by deception program. Hopefully organisers can swallow their attitude and work together behind closed doors to present a united and cohesive protest that will have an impact, get published by the Media and get politicians to realise just how many votes are at risk.

4

Nathan

Mon 08/03/2010 - 13:18

I signed the petition in Brisbane against the filter. It was small, and there needs to be more support to stop the filter.

5

anonymous

Mon 08/03/2010 - 13:32

Re comment 1 by Max T, perhaps the mainstream media really like the idea of the filter.

The system of secret government censorship could be expanded to control some content downloads, and free access to information, as well as anything else the government would prefer us not to know.

6

Ben

Mon 08/03/2010 - 14:25

I dont know what time that photo (perth) was taken but it certainly wasnt at 12:15pm. there was huge queues lining up to sign the petition, I waited for 15 mins in the queue before giving up and deciding to come back later. I also cna see that the photos are positioned to fulfil the article needs rather than what really happen.

7

Simon Shaw

Mon 08/03/2010 - 17:26

Why publicly protest?

The government doesn't care about street protests.
With 100'000's marching against the Iraq war and politicians just ignored the people and went to war anyway.

These protests were also badly organised, with dates changing and other groups vying for attention. It was quite pathetic.

Maybe a mailing list would be a good idea next time instead of Facebook or MySpace which a lot of people refuse to use.

8

Michael

Mon 08/03/2010 - 19:13

The picture of the crowd at the Perth protest is totally misrepresentative, it appears to be taken on the stroke of midday. By about ten minutes past midday, about 150 people had assembled, the crowd turnout was actually pretty decent. Both petitions were enthusiastically signed, and the location was much better than last year's, being directly in front of the city's train station, we had a steady flow of passers-by picking up on the loudspeakers and stopping to listen.
The main problem with the rally appears to be getting the word out. Even those very familiar with the issue had trouble finding out when/where these rallies were planned to be held. Creating an event posting on Facebook is NOT the way to do this.

9

Stop supporting BIG OIL

Tue 09/03/2010 - 02:38

Lets be honest most geeks dont here don't want the filter because it may effect their ability to play Violent Games

10

Trish Zanetti

Tue 09/03/2010 - 03:30

As someone else pointed out, the photo above is not a good reflection of the crowd that came out in Perth.

At the height of the rally I estimate up to 300 people were there listening to the speakers.

We got hundreds of signatures on petitions, we marched and many of the protestors were at their first ever protest.

Numbers were effected by the amount of time we had to promote the event, considering Stop the Filter only started up 4 weeks ago, and due to an environmental rally that was held on the same day - and people gearing up for the ACDC concert.

We did promote the rally outside of Facebook as much as possible - we sent press releases, spoke on 3 different radio shows, had coverage in the Perth Voice, as well as word going out on various contact email lists - and put posters in internet cafes and other shops that would allow us to, as soon as we could.

In spite of being interviewed by the West Australian - the only mainstream newspaper in Perth - they chose not to run with the story.

Against the odds we got a decent crowd and I personally thought that it was informative, productive and entertaining.

Special thanks to the band Project Mayhem, who came on board in the days just prior to the rally and agreed to play on the day. It was the icing on the cake.

Anyone who would like to help us with an ongoing campaign and future events is welcome to come to our next organising meeting. Please email stopthefilter@iinet.net.au.

Trish Zanetti
Stop the Filter

11

CW Journo - Darren Pauli

Tue 09/03/2010 - 09:38

Hi Trish,
That's great news about the attendance numbers. We were told by alleged attendees corroborated with online comments that the attendance was small, and so I've updated the story.
Congratuations on a succesful day.
Darren

12

shaz salimian (sydney)

Wed 10/03/2010 - 07:26

re- this part of article
"Sydney protest organizer, Shaz Salimian, said attendees at the Parramatta rally had decided with-- Rhiannon--- to re-organise under a new group free of political agenda.
"[The] Net Freedom Coalition will unify [groups] to stop the Internet filter. All groups are welcome and will not feel threatened that a political party will take advantage," Salimian said in an online video.said in an online video."

Rhiannon never agreed to anything and she did not come to the meeting after wards the only thing i asked her was on stage and that was would she be willing to provide public liability insurance like the parramatta event that block the filter organized that day for a city protest /rally event where she answered with only" contact me or someone in my office " she never agreed to or did i mention her agreeing to anything in my vid about a working with other political groups in unity for
net freedom coalition events that my vision for was a unity of all political groups free of point scoring etc

13

Darren Pauli

Wed 10/03/2010 - 08:22

Hi Shaz, apologies for the mix up, i've updated the story.

14

Trish Zanetti

Sat 13/03/2010 - 21:12

Thanks Darren,

All is forgiven :-)

Feel free to contact me for an interview with regards to future stories about Stop the Filter activities.

Thanks again.

Trish Zanetti
Stop the Filter
stopthefilter@iinet.net.au

15

Trish Zanetti

Sat 13/03/2010 - 22:12

Ha ha, just saw the "usual suspects" comment Darren! That is very wrong too. Most the people were people I have never seen at a rally before in Perth! Many were young and attending their first ever protest.

Most ot "the usual suspects" must have been at the environmental rally.

Rgds Trish Zanetti
stopthefilter@iinet.net.au

16

Freda

Sun 14/03/2010 - 02:01

I was at the Sydney rally. We had people who had never protested before including people who didn't know about the filter until they learned about it on the day.

We also had the loudspeakers booming down Macquarie Street, and people coming from within Parramatta Park, and local press coverage, as well as several people taking video of the speeches.

Focusing on just the perceived numbers says little. For example there are approximately, 400,000 Facebook users that have joined groups against the filter.

If each of those represents unique Australian citizens, I think Conroy has a problem.

But like others have said, Facebook is a terrible medium for organising protestors. People say they will come (in Sydney, around 710 people said they would come, and 13,000 for the NDA more generally) but they don't.

Facebook makes people lazy and distracted. It's too easy. But that doesn't mean there aren't a lot of people who are already against Conroy's policy.

Unfortunately, sometimes you have to go where people are, and they tend to be on Facebook these days......

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the Computerworld comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Coverage
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Tags: protest, internet content filtering
Whitepapers
All whitepapers
Sign up now to get free exclusive access to reports, research and invitation only events.
Featured Download

Computerworld newsletter

Join the most dedicated community for IT managers, leaders and professionals in Australia