Linux shortlisted for DET netbooks, beaten by XP
- 07 April, 2009 09:35
- Comments 3
The DET's new netbooks will ship with the older Windows XP, not Linux or Mac OS X
Today's modern desktop operating systems of Windows Vista, Apple Mac OS X, and Linux still fail to address the basic requirements of the NSW Department of Education and Training's netbook project and instead the older Windows XP remains the platform of choice for more than 260,000 computers.
Last week the DET announced it will spend some $150 million on netbooks for school staff and students, which is great for the education revolution, but the anomaly is the hardware will be delivered with an eight-year-old operating system pre-installed, which is also one generation behind Microsoft's most recent desktop effort, Windows Vista.
While Apple doesn't offer a “netbook” as such, there's no reason why Mac OS X could not be included in the purchase, the computers would just be full notebooks, not smaller netbooks.
TechWorld decided to investigate why the DET went with XP over Linux, and operating system that helped make the netbook famous by offering a small footprint alternative to Windows.
A spokesperson for NSW DET CIO Stephen Wilson said the public call for expressions of interest issued on December 3, 2008 “did not state a preference concerning operating systems and applications”.
The playing field was level at the start, apparently.
“A range of operating systems that met the requirements were presented as part of the expression of interest process, including solutions based on Apple, Linux and Microsoft platforms,” the spokesperson said.
“Following the evaluation of all responses against common selection criteria, the restricted request for proposals issued on February 17, 2009 to shortlisted respondents, specified a Linux or Microsoft platform.”
So according to the DET, all three were considered and Linux make the shortlist, but was pipped at the post by the venerable XP.
“The NSW Department of Education and Training determined that a Microsoft-based solution best met its needs at this time,” the spokesperson said.
It what may amount to a simple case of bad timing for the department, it will conduct a large-scale deployment of Windows XP with a year of the scheduled release of Microsoft's next generation operating system, Windows 7.
However, the DET has committed to leapfrogging Windows Vista and upgrading to Windows 7 on the netbooks when it is available. For 260,000 netbooks that's no mean feat.
“The vendor will install the Laptops 4 Learning (L4L) standard operating environment image on all laptops before delivery as part of its contractual obligations,” the spokesperson said.
“Windows XP will be the platform installed initially. NSW DET intends upgrading to Windows 7 at a time yet to be determined.”
- Bookmark this page
- Share this article
- Got more on this story? Email Computerworld
- Follow Computerworld on twitter
-
CSIRO claims world's fastest wireless link
-
CeBit 2012: Social media a legal minefield
-
VOIP a wake-up call for global phone competition
-
CeBIT 2012: Will NBN speed up freight delivery times?
-
HTC announces Titan 4G
-
MYOB Software for Dummies 6E Australian Edition
-
Excel 2007 All-In-One Desk Reference for Dummies
-
Windows 7 for Dummies®
-
Windows 7 for Seniors for Dummies®
-
Office 2007 for Dummies
-
Office 2007 All-In-One Desk Reference for Dummies
-
Windows 7 for Dummies® Dvd+book Bundle
-
Computers for Seniors for Dummies, 2nd Edition
-
Teach Yourself Visually Windows 7
Comments
Anonymous
DET
TechWorld decided to investigate why the DET went with XP over Linux?
Your article has not explained at all why DET decided on Win XP. My personal belief is that Microsoft is firmly entrenched into the heads of IT in Australia and that these people are either too scared or want to play it safe by sticking to what they know. With the extra antivirus software that XP needs and the fact that they will run in Admin mode I fail to see how this is a good solution. Another waste of taxpayer dollars - look at what the French Police have done by moving entirely to Open Source (perhaps the Victorian Police could take note before it's too late).
Treebeard
One wonders....
Will the,
One wonders....
Will the, ahem, 'Laptops 4 Learning (L4L) standard operating environment' run on Linux?
If not, then the DET is pulling our collective chain in making us think they really ever intended to consider Linux netbooks.
If your SOE wont run on Linux, then you've already locked yourself in to Microsoft's gameplan, right?
If they really want to convince anyone, release the damn detailed comparison analysis - that is, assuming they did one. The rest is just smoke and mirrors.
Scott Rippon
Dear TechWorld
Just have a
Dear TechWorld
Just have a few questions:
1. What was the tender number for this tender?
Through freedom of information (FOI) is it possible to see:
2. See what free software organisations submitted tenders?
3. See Microsoft's and the other free software tenders?
4. See the evaluation criteria to better understand why free software alternatives were "pipped at the post by the venerable XP"?
5. Have just read that Windows 7 will be rolled out instead of WinXP (http://www.computerworld.com.au/article/316261/windows_7_enabled_netbooks_schools_include_open_source_software). This is probably a dumb question but how does the choice/decision get made to go from WinXP, which won the tender, to using Win7 which isn't even available to the public yet?
Thanks in advance.
Kind regards,
Scott.
Post new comment