Computerworld
Was MythBuster's RFID tale only a myth?
Was it industry pressure, protection of advertising revenue, or a simple storyline change that saw the RFID segment pulled from Mythbuster's schedule?
Paul McNamara (Network World)  05 September, 2008 10:07

It all started when Adam Savage of MythBusters fame told a convention audience that legal bullies from the credit card industry had cowed Discovery Channel into scotching an episode of the show that was to have taken on RFID.

In the video, Savage says: "Here's what happened -- I'm not sure how much of this story I'm allowed to tell -- but I'll tell you what I know. We were going to do RFID -- on several levels: how reliable, how hackable, how trackable, etc. -- and one of our researchers called up Texas Instruments and they arranged a conference call."

He wasn't on the call himself, but continues: "Texas Instruments comes on along with chief legal counsel for American Express, VISA, Discover [Card], and everybody else. They absolutely made it really clear to Discovery [Channel] that they were not going to air this episode talking about how hackable this stuff was. Discovery backed way down, being a large corporation that depends upon the revenue of the advertisers. Now that [topic is] on Discovery's radar and they won't let us go near it. I'm sorry, it's just one of those things."

Savage's incendiary accusation went relatively unnoticed at the time, but caught fire on the Internet over the Labor Day weekend fanned by prominent placement on forums such as Slashdot and Digg. Days later it became clear Savage was considerably less knowledgeable about what transpired than he let on, although how much of his backtracking is backside-covering will be left open to speculation.

Here's his statement from last week as provided by Discovery Channel: "There's been a lot of talk about this RFID thing, and I have to admit that I got some of my facts wrong, as I wasn't on that story, and as I said on the video, I wasn't actually in on the call. . . . If I went into the detail of exactly why this story didn't get filmed, it's so bizarre and convoluted that no one would believe me, but suffice to say . . . the decision not to continue on with the RFID story was made by our production company, Beyond Productions, and had nothing to do with Discovery or their ad sales department."

That's not all that Savage got wrong. Jon Drummond, a PR guy at Discover Financial Services, tells me: "The statement that Discover participated in the call that was mentioned in the video is incorrect. Discover legal counsel did not participate in any such call." American Express told me the same thing.

And here's what Texas Instruments sent: "In June 2007, MythBusters was interested in pursuing some great myth-busting ideas for RFID. While in pursuit, they contacted Texas Instruments' RFID Systems . . . for technical help and understanding of RFID in the contactless payments space. Some of the information that was needed to pursue the program required further support from the contactless payment companies, as they construct their own proprietary systems for security to protect their customers. To move the process along, Texas Instruments coordinated a conversation with Smart Card Alliance (SCA) which invited MasterCard and Visa, on contactless payments to help MythBusters get the right information.

"Of the handful of people on the call, there were mostly product managers and only one contactless payment company's legal counsel member. Technical questions were asked and answered, and we were to wait for MythBusters to let us know when the segment would air. A few weeks later, Texas Instruments was told by MythBusters that the storyline had changed and they were pursuing a different angle which did not require our help."

So what really happened? You can take the corporate spokespeople at their words . . . no, really, you can, since Savage has all but said he suffered some sort of brain cramp.

However, having spent 30 years in the news business, I'm not quite so sure that the funnyman MythBuster simply woke up on the wrong side of the bed the day he spilled his guts to a roomful of geeks while a video camera rolled. Wouldn't surprise me in the least if the truth actually lies somewhere between Savage's moment of unguarded/ill-informed candor and subsequent change of tune.

It's exactly the kind of mystery that MythBusters might ... uh, never mind.

Comments

Post new comment

Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Enter the fully qualified URL, eg. http://www.example.com/
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Discussions on Mobility & Wireless
Zones
Zone logoZones provide focussed content from Computerworld and leading technology partners.
Newsletter Subscription
Newsletter Subscription
Sign up for our Computerworld newsletters!
Syndicate content Syndicate content Syndicate content Syndicate content
 
Motorola Knowledge Centre
PARTNER CONTENT


How do you install a 21st Century network into a 12th Century castle?

Watch this video to find out more

Learn more about the enterprise beyond wires:

Click to read whitepaper

Topline considerations when planning your 802.11n network, and how to streamline the implementation process:

Click to read whitepaper

Or view the webcast instead, noted analyst Craig Mathias of the Farpoint Group explains the technology and offers tips for how to successfully deploy 802.11n to support an all-wireless network.

Click to listen to webcast

Wi-Fi attitudes shift: what's yours?

In August 2008, the Webtorials editorial/analyst division surveyed the webtorials subscriber base concerning enterprise wireless LAN (WLAN) depoyment plans, attitudes and experiences.

Download this report now to discover current attitudes and plans concerning WLAN technologies

Reliable and secure wireless networking

This webinar will cover:

  • Current PTP deployments supporting tactical communications, security operations, video surveillance and VoIP
  • How to establish communications in challenging conditions
  • Cost-effective alternatives to leased T1 lines

Click to view webinar

ENTERPRISE

Kilkenny Castle Video Case Study
See a 12th century castle that has successfully deployed a 21st century network.

Untethered Enterprise White Paper
Learn more about the enterprise beyond wires.

SECURITY

WLAN Security – What Hackers Know that you don't
This paper advocates a layered approach to wireless LAN security that goes beyond new encryption and authentication standards to include 24x7 monitoring to identify rogue wireless LANs, detect intruders and attacks, enforce network security policies and monitor the health of the wireless LAN.

Three steps for Bullet-Proof Wireless LAN Security & Management
This white paper outlines a systematic approach for securing all network components.

Government & Public Sector Solutions<
Learn about secure, resilient wireless network solutions that are truly wireless, inside and out.

Wireless protection in the Mobile Workforce
This paper addresses the security challenges faced by an enterprise submerged in a pervasive wireless environment.

11n INDOOR WIRELESS

802.11n: look before you leap
This white paper discusses the many steps to consider when planning your 802.11n network, and offers some solutions to streamlining the implementation process.

LANPlanner: The Ultimate Planning tool
Motorola LANPlanner combines powerful predictive modeling technology with an easy-to-use interface to take the guesswork out of deploying an 11n network, whether you’re working from a clean slate environment, a "rip and replace" scenario or a mixed deployment with legacy and 11n equipment.

Free Industry Report: Enterprise Strategies for 802.11n
Take a look at what factors are driving your peers toward 802.11n adoption, what challenges they.re facing and the different approaches they're taking to deploy 11n in their enterprises in this 2008 Webtorial Wireless LAN State-of-the-Market Report.

OUTDOOR WIRELESS

Webinar: Wireless & Secure Networks
This webinar features: Current PTP deployments supporting tactical communications, security operations, video surveillance and VoIP How to establish communications in challenging conditions Cost-effective alternatives to leased T1 lines

Computerworld Community Comments
Enterprise IT Buyer's Guide
Find Technology Vendors Fast
 
Find vendors by name | Find by category
Sponsored Links
 
Send Us E-mail | Privacy Policy
Features List | Media Kit | Advertising | Contact Us

Copyright 2009 IDG Communications. ABN 14 001 592 650. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of IDG Communications is prohibited.