Computerworld
Report ticks filtered Internet
ISP content filters to go live “soon”.
Darren Pauli  29 July, 2008 08:18

The government's clean feed Internet scheme has been buoyed by glowing results from tests into the effectiveness of Internet Service Provider (ISP) content filters.

The Australian Communications and Media Authority's (ACMA) Internet content filtering report, the latest of a series that was first commissioned in 1993, claims the technology has undergone massive improvements since 2005 when that year's trial returned abysmal results.

ISP content filtering is part of the government's $125.8 million Plan for Cyber Safety which will split funds between law enforcement, technology and education to reduce the proliferation of child porn and inappropriate content.

Communications Minister Stephen Conroy said the government will soon trial blocking prohibited and "additional" material in a live pilot with ISPs using the filters.

"The next step is to test filter technologies in a real world environment with a number of ISPs and internet users," Conroy said.

"Filtering specifically against a black-list of illegal content as well as the ability to filter additional material will be one part of the upcoming pilot trial.

"This will enable the implementation of ISP filtering in Australia to be undertaken in an informed and effective way."

The ACMA test of six Internet content filters showed the worst performer allowed through 12 percent of a set list of banned material, while the best blocked more than 94 percent.

Fewer than one percent returned false positives, and five of the six consumed less than one percent of network resources when attached but not filtering.

When actively filtering, one product chewed up to 75 percent of network resources, three used between 22 to 30 percent and one tool used less than one percent.

None of the products could identify banned material via Peer-to-Peer (P2P) file sharing networks, although one product was able to identify blocked material in "media streaming".

"Despite the general nature of advances in ISP level filtering technology between the current trial and the previous trial, most filters are not presently able to identify illegal content, and content that may be regarded as inappropriate that is carried via the majority of non-Web protocols," the report stated.

Results for the 2005 test were so bad that the search for ISP-level filters was abandoned and replaced with enterprise-level solutions. The average network resource consumption returned in the test was between 75 to 98 percent.

The ACMA test was conducted on an isolated analogous Tier 3 ISP network in Telstra's broadband e-Lab by vendor Enex TestLab. Only six from an initial 26 solutions passed the three phases of criteria; however the names of the products were kept confidential.

More about Tier 3, Telstra, VIA

Comments

Completely useless

These filters will not be able to block illegal traffic.
-Popular internet proxies with SSL encryption make web requests undetectable and unenforceable without compromised hosts or timing attacks. This is probably illegal, but is also completely impractical, as there are literally thousands of such proxies in abundance. This also makes it difficult to set up honeypots.
-Much dangerous, organised crime / terrorism-related activities (as well as a number of diplomats, spies, etc) utilise the TOR network,which provides onion routing (look it up). This routes web requests through a number of hops, encrypting it along the way, such that the client remains anonymous. This is widely in use in China to bypass the Great Firewall. Even China isn't able to block this -- we don't stand a chance.

Long story short, the content filtering is only useful for making sure Joe Public can't visit a subset of pornographic websites, or sites with dangerous political ideas. And as usual, the real criminals who trade in illegal pornography, plan terrorist attacks, hack into websites, import vast quantities of drugs, etc go completely unhindered and unpunished.

I Love The Onion

*chuckle*

Man, The Onion does have some hilarious news stories. Just imagine if this actually happened. Oh, those jokers.

...........wait, WHAT!?

Filtered Internet??

Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
- Benjamin Franklin

This is the thin end of the wedge, what next, shall we censor newspapers, radio and TV?

Andrew

Post new comment

Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Zones
Zone logoZones provide focussed content from Computerworld and leading technology partners.
Newsletter Subscription
Newsletter Subscription
Sign up for our Computerworld newsletters!
Syndicate content
 

Computerworld Webinar

Thursday, June 11th, 2009
10:30am EST (Sydney, Australia)
Screening at your PC

Computerworld is hosting a 30 minute live webinar to help you to learn how unified communications can save you money, foster innovation and business agility by making it easier for people to find, reach and collaborate with one another.

Register Now

Computerworld Community Comments
Whitepaper

Providing Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery for Microsoft Cluster Server and Windows Server 08 Failover Clustering Apps

Clustering provides high availability for mission critical applications. A well implemented cluster tolerates failure of individual components to deliver a much increased level of availability and resilience. Get implementation tips now.

Enterprise IT Buyer's Guide
Find Technology Vendors Fast
 
Find vendors by name | Find by category
Sponsored Links
 
Send Us E-mail | Privacy Policy
Features List | Media Kit | Advertising | Contact Us

Copyright 2009 IDG Communications. ABN 14 001 592 650. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of IDG Communications is prohibited.